كثير أفكار على نساء أدوار في الكنيسة

[إينستد وف] يستمرّ النقاشة أنّ يبدأ في ال [كمّنت سكأيشن] من موقعتي سابقة على الدور النساء في قيادة, أنا قد قرّرت أن يضيف موقعة جديدة.

أنا أبدا أقنعت أنّ يحظّر [سكريبتثر] ال يتدرّب من قيادة أو يعلم من رجال بنساء. هو ليس كثيرا أنّ أقنعت أنا تماما أنّ [سكريبتثر] يعلم موقعة مساواتيّة. هو أكثر أنّ لا يقنع أنا من الموقعة [كمبلنترين]. يعطي هذا حقيقة, ضلّ أنا بالأحرى على الجانب من نعمة وحرية. ويقول حقيقة, أنا [فري موش] مساواتيّة في قلب. وبما أنّ أنا لا أشعر وكأنّ هو ضدّ [سكريبتثر] أو قناعتي أن يكون مساواتيّة, يركض أنا [غلدلي] مع هو.

ومع ذلك, أحبّ أنا أن يشبك في [ا بيت وف] تأويل. أنا لست كتاب مقدّس [سكهولر-فر] من [إيت-بوت] يسمحني أن يعالج واحدة من الأكثر يصعب ممرات في ال [نو تستمنت] لموقعات مساواتيّة. [إين فكت], يبدو كثير ممرات بسهولة بكفاية للحشد مساواتيّة أن يخاطب, مع واحدة استثناء: 1 تيموثي 2:11 - 15…

تركت إمرأة علمت بهدوء مع كلّ [سوبميسّيفنسّ]. أنا لا أسمح إمرأة أن يعلم أو أن يتدرّب سلطة على رجل; بالأحرى, هو أن يبقى يسجو. شكّلت لآدم كان أولى, بعد ذلك عشية; ولم يخدع آدم كان, غير أنّ الإمرأة كان خدعت وأصبح [ترنسغرسّور]. مع ذلك سينقذ هو كنت كلّيّا [شلدبرينغ-يف] هم يستمرّون في إيمان وحالة حبّ وقداسة, مع [سلف-كنترول].

هنا ي يقرأ على هذا ممر. The “submissiveness” here doesn’t seem to be “submissiveness” to men, but submissiveness to God or to the assembly. Being unsubmissive, then, doesn’t mean that they had the audacity to lead men or the audacity to speak up. Being unsubmissive means that they were not yielding appropriately to Christ and/or the assembly.

Paul cannot mean that women cannot teach in a broad sense–it must be a very specific sense of teaching (since there are examples in Scripture of women teaching in different senses. I agree that there are cases when women cannot teach. I simply don’t think there is a universal principle here. I also don’t think that women, by default, should be kept from leadership or teaching roles. But the key to understanding this particular situation is that Paul contrasts “teaching and having authority over men” with remaining quiet. Clearly, women are not always to remain silent, since elsewhere in the Pauline canon Paul instructs women in the proper way of prophesying and whatnot.

So, then, this is a particular case when women are to be quiet, rather than in teaching or exercising authority. Why is it that we make this a universal teaching, when it is clearly a particular instance in which we cannot see all the issues readily within the text?

You might say “Mark, you cannot so easily dismiss the complementarian reading of this text, for this teaching is rooted in the creation order!” Fair enough. And it is this reality that renders this the most problematic passage to the egalitarian. However, this passage only makes the point that women should be submissive…and since the earlier use of this word doesn’t seem to refer to male-female relations, then this doesn’t seem to argue for a gender hierarchy, but for women to be submissive.

This is hardly an original thought, but given all of this, I cannot help but think that the situation of that ancient congregation involved a group of women acting in a way that was not appropriate. I do not think that the inappropriate situation was that women were merely teaching men and acting in an eldering capacity. The situation was that unsubmissive women (in my earlier sense of the word) were teaching and having authority. Instead, they should learn from their mother Eve, who was deceived. The implication is that these particular women are being deceived. This seems like a valid interpretation. After all, in 2 Cor 11:3 Paul uses Eve as an example of anyone who is deceived.

The reason this passage is interpreted the way it is by complementarians is that they seem to assume that what Paul means by “submissive” is “submissive to men” and that the reference to Adam and Eve is meant to demonstrate a universal status for men and women. Instead, I think that submission is meant in a broader sense and that the reference to Adam and Eve is an admonition to eschew deception. These particular women are being inappropriate in their manner of teaching and having authority and as a result, Paul instructs the women to be quiet.

for further reading . . .

• None Found